Back to home

Compare

Comparing: DeepSeek Slices Agent Runtime Into Lego — China's LLM Firms Sell Foundations & DeepSeek 把 AI Agent 运行时拆成三层乐高 — 中国大模型公司开始卖地基

AEN
DeepSeekHarnessAgent·

DeepSeek Slices Agent Runtime Into Lego — China's LLM Firms Sell Foundations

DeepSeek open-sourced a CLI tool called Harness this week, decomposing the AI Agent (an autonomous program that invokes tools to complete tasks) runtime into three pluggable Lego-like layers—but the team has officially labeled it a developer preview, and interfaces may change at any time.

What this is

Think of an Agent as a "worker" that operates the computer and calls tools on its own; Harness is that worker's workbench. It's not simply a model wrapped around a terminal—it turns every component—model adapters (connectors that bring different LLMs on board), tool registries, session archives, sandbox (isolated secure runtime) policies, and the main loop driving multi-turn calls—into swappable plugins.

The architecture splits into three layers. The outermost is a composition layer of Profiles and Bundles that stack capabilities in sequence; the middle is the runtime backbone handling data flow for a single conversation; the innermost layer uses Session logs as the source of truth. The team calls this design "everything is a plugin"—even the main loop itself is a plugin, and can be replaced. To change capabilities, you don't edit core code—you attach plugins and events.

Industry view

Our read: this step moves DeepSeek from "selling models" to "selling foundations." Chinese LLM vendors used to compete on parameters and benchmark scores; now they're digging ecosystem moats—open-sourcing infrastructure so developers build on their foundations.

Supporters argue the design hits enterprise needs squarely: auditable and replaceable—the two points compliance teams in finance and healthcare care about most. The clean three-layer split also means plugging in new models or tools requires no changes to the core repo.

Critics raise at least three concerns. First, DeepSeek itself states interfaces will see breaking changes—what you learn today may be obsolete next quarter; can enterprise production environments bet on that? Second, the underlying Cordis framework originated from the QQ bot community Koishi, with limited production-scale validation—financial-grade stability is questionable. Third, while the architecture is elegant, the learning curve is steep; ordinary developers may not want to invest the effort.

Impact on regular people

  • For enterprise IT: worth having the tech team evaluate the approach, but don't bet production on it short-term—wait for the interface to stabilize across one or two versions.
  • For individual professionals: non-developers don't need to learn this now; developers can watch whether the Cordis plugin ecosystem takes off, but don't rush to fork.
  • For consumer markets: no short-term impact visible; long-term, if the ecosystem matures, more AI Agent products may run on DeepSeek models.
Source: juejin.cn
BZH
DeepSeekHarnessAgent·

DeepSeek 把 AI Agent 运行时拆成三层乐高 — 中国大模型公司开始卖地基

DeepSeek 这周开源了一个叫 Harness 的命令行工具,把 AI Agent(智能体,能自主调用工具完成任务的程序)的运行时拆成三层可拼装的乐高——但官方明示这是 developer preview,接口随时会变。

这是什么

把 Agent 想成一个能自己操作电脑、调用工具的「打工人」,Harness 就是这个打工人的工作台。它不是简单地把大模型套上终端,而是把所有组件——模型适配器(让不同大模型接入的转接头)、工具注册表、会话存档、沙箱(安全隔离的运行环境)策略、驱动多轮调用的主循环——都做成可替换插件。

架构分三层。最外层是 Profile 和 Bundle 的组合层,按顺序叠加就拼出能力;中间是运行时主干,负责一次对话的数据流;最内层以 Session 日志为事实源。官方把这种设计叫「一切皆插件」——连主循环自己也是插件,能被替换。改能力不用改主代码,挂插件、挂事件就行。

行业怎么看

我们的判断:DeepSeek 这步是从「卖模型」转向「卖地基」。中国大模型公司以前拼参数、拼榜单,现在开始建生态护城河——把基础设施开源出去,让开发者在自家地基上盖房子。

支持者认为这套设计正中企业级需求:可审计、可替换,金融、医疗的合规团队最在意这两点。三层切分清楚也意味着接入新模型、新工具不用改主仓库。

反对意见至少有三条。第一,官方自己写明接口会 breaking change,今天学的接口下季度可能就过期,企业生产环境敢押注吗?第二,底层的 Cordis 框架源自 QQ 机器人社区 Koishi,生产环境大规模验证少,金融级稳定性存疑。第三,架构虽优雅但学习曲线陡峭,普通开发者未必愿意啃。

对普通人的影响

  • 企业 IT:值得让技术团队评估思路,但短期不要押注生产,等接口稳定一两个版本。
  • 个人职场:非开发者不必现在学;开发者可观察 Cordis 插件生态能不能起来,不要急着 fork。
  • 消费市场:短期看不到影响;长期若生态成熟,更多 AI Agent 产品可能用上 DeepSeek 模型。
Source: juejin.cn