Back to home

Compare

Comparing: A Client Says “Make a Promo Video”—Why AI Can’t Finish the Job & 客户只说“做个宣传视频”,AI 为什么总交不出成品

AEN
小影科技垂直Agent短视频创作者·

A Client Says “Make a Promo Video”—Why AI Can’t Finish the Job

Last Wednesday, a client replied with one line: “Make me a promo video.” I froze again.

At 10 p.m., I was staring at an editing timeline in a Hangzhou café. My client sold handmade bread and wanted a weekend promo, but hadn’t specified the visual style, promotion angle, or publishing platform. I used to ask a round of questions, then keep editing until midnight. Now I handed the brief to a general-purpose AI. It could write a script, but still couldn’t deliver the finished video. I felt a little panicked: the tools keep getting stronger, so why does the work still land on me?

This isn’t a general assistant—it’s a vertical Agent that understands a type of business

Han Sheng, founder of Xiaoying Technology, described a more concrete scenario: a burger shop wants a weekend promotion. The Agent first needs to understand who its customers are and what makes the products worth buying, then select footage, structure the content, and judge whether the finished video can drive in-store visits. That goes beyond “generating a video.” It puts professional judgment inside the workflow.

A vertical Agent is more like a colleague responsible for one defined job. A general assistant is the omniscient butler; a specialist is the operations partner who knows store marketing inside out. For work that is frequent, specialized, and process-heavy, the specialist’s value becomes obvious. The first version usually isn’t delivered as-is either: users still provide feedback, request changes, and only then receive something usable.

How I’d reproduce this approach on a low budget today

Money: I wouldn’t buy expensive software upfront. I’d test the workflow with the AI tools I already have plus a monthly cost of RMB 0–300. Time: I’d build a minimum version in two hours. Technical barrier: coding isn’t required, but I need to explain “how I normally do this” step by step. First step: open my usual AI chat tool, start a conversation named “Short-Video Planning,” and enter: “Break my client’s one-line brief into target audience, core selling points, shot list, storyboard, and revision criteria.”

I made this mistake too: at first, I told AI to “just edit a video,” and all I got was text that looked like a script. What worked was starting with one real client case, then recording every follow-up question and revision criterion until it became a repeatable process.

Here’s how I’d test it at each stage

If I’m just starting out, I’d choose one service I know well, such as shooting event videos for local businesses, and accept only one or two standardized packages instead of rushing to build an “everything for everyone” platform. If I already have one or two clients, I’d turn their briefs into templates: background, goals, shot list, number of revisions, and acceptance criteria. That would make each delivery more consistent. If I’m scaling, I’d build a specialist assistant for the slowest, most experience-dependent part of delivery rather than spreading the budget evenly across every feature.

This tool isn’t for everyone. If my business doesn’t have stable demand yet, waiting is fine; serving a few clients by hand is often more valuable than building a system first. AI coding makes “building it” easier, but the scarce skill is knowing what the client actually wants—and being able to deliver it consistently.

BZH
小影科技垂直Agent短视频创作者·

客户只说“做个宣传视频”,AI 为什么总交不出成品

上周三,客户只回了一句“帮我做个宣传视频”,我又卡住了

晚上十点,我在杭州的咖啡馆盯着剪辑时间线:客户卖手工面包,想做周末促销片,却没说画面风格、促销重点和发布平台。以前我会追问一轮,再自己剪到半夜。现在把需求丢给通用 AI,它能写脚本,却还是没替我完成交付。我也有点慌:工具越来越强,为什么活还是落在人身上?

这不是一个通用助手,而是懂某类生意的垂直 Agent

小影科技创始人韩晟举了个更具体的场景:汉堡店要做周末促销,Agent 得先弄清顾客是谁、产品卖点是什么,再选素材、组织内容,最后判断这条片能不能带来到店消费。这不是“生成一段视频”那么简单,而是把专业判断放进流程。

垂直 Agent 更像一位只负责特定任务的同事。通用助手像知道很多事的“老管家”;专业助手则像熟悉门店营销的运营搭档。高频、专业、流程复杂的活儿,后者的价值更明显。第一版通常也不会直接交付,用户还要反馈、修改,最后才得到可用作品。

你今天怎么低成本复刻这套思路

钱:不用先买昂贵软件,拿现有 AI 工具加 0~300 元月费即可试跑。时间:先用 2 小时做一个最小版本。技术门槛:不需要会编程,但要愿意把“我平时怎么做”一步步说清楚。第一步:打开你常用的 AI 对话工具,新建一个名为“短视频策划”的对话,输入“帮我把客户的一句话需求拆成:目标观众、核心卖点、素材清单、分镜、修改标准”。

我之前也犯过这个错:一上来就让 AI“直接剪一条”,结果它给的只是看起来像脚本的文字。正确做法是先拿一个真实客户案例跑通,再把每次追问和修改标准记下来,逐步做成固定流程。

如果你正处在不同阶段,我会这样试

如果你刚起步,我会先选一个最熟悉的服务,比如给本地商家拍活动视频,只接一两种固定单,别急着做“大而全”的平台。如果你已有 1~2 个客户,我会把他们的需求变成模板:背景、目标、镜头清单、修改次数和验收标准都留下来,让每次交付更稳定。如果你在扩规模,我会先找交付里最耗时、最依赖经验的一环做专门助手,而不是把预算平均分给所有功能。

这工具不是所有人都需要。如果你的业务还没有稳定需求,现在不试也没事;先亲手服务几个客户,往往比先搭系统更重要。AI 编程让“做出来”变容易了,但真正稀缺的是:知道客户到底要什么,并能持续交付结果。